24 Aug, 2011
Posted by: Neil Clarke In: Hugo Rules
The committee proposal survived the business meeting in Reno last week. There were some revision to the fanzine portion of the proposal, but otherwise the amendments that would have hurt semiprozines were defeated. The big news out of the meeting was the passage of a proposal for Best Fancast, which will move podcasts into their [...]
If you are attending Worldcon in Reno this week and have an interest in semiprozines, we are once again calling on your support. There are two business meetings that may very well reshape the boundaries of the Best Semiprozine Hugo Award. Quite often, people overlook the importance of the first business meeting, but this one [...]
14 Aug, 2011
Posted by: Neil Clarke In: Hugo Rules
It seems that some fans disgruntled over the fact that podcasts can compete in fanzine or semiprozine have submitted their own proposal for modifications to the semiprozine and fanzine categories to kick them out. The semiprozine committee saw this proposal before completing theirs and specifically chose not to include it. Even if you don’t think [...]
This blog has been silent for a while. It has been nearly two years since the attempt to eliminate the Semiprozine Hugo was defeated and committee assigned to take on the task of fixing an obviously outdated and broken definition. You can read the committee’s 2011 report, proposal and some minority reports (committee members who [...]